I’ve wrote about this film and this soundtrack before, but an awesome screening of Tim Burton’s film on Sunday evening at the glorious Hollywood Avondale gives me a good reason to write again, this time while spinning the 2018 expanded 2xLP reissue from Mondo.
Now, I love an expanded score as much as the next man – Mondo had given us the expanded 3xLP reissue of BATMAN RETURNS a year earlier in 2017 – but I just wish Mondo would take a bit more care in their packaging and liner notes. The faux pas here is that, just a few short years after his death, the final line of the (otherwise brilliantly conceived) liner notes states that ‘Mondo would like to dedicate this re-issue to Prince Rogers Neslon (sic)’.
The same year, Mondo credited the director of HALLOWEEN III: SEASON OF THE WITCH in their beautiful reissue as Tommy Lee Jones, rather than Tommy Lee Wallace. Thankfully I haven’t noticed anything as jarring in the last couple of years.
Seeing Burton’s film again on the big screen – my first time since opening night in August 1989 – was an absolute delight, but with even more water under the bridge since we’ve had Christopher Nolan’s interpretations, it feels like a much weaker film than the last time I saw it, roughly ten years ago when it was first released on Blu-Ray.
The studio-heavy production design feels inauthentic, the screen ratio is weirdly narrow, and the narrative is almost infantile in its simplicity – we’ve all got used to so many revolving storylines, particularly in contemporary comic-book movie fare. But as NZ film critic Dom Corry recently pointed out, Burton’s BATMAN belongs on the Mt Rushmore of comic book movies alongside Donner’s SUPERMAN, Raimi’s SPIDER-MAN and Favreau’s IRON MAN. It might not be perfect, but its charm lies in how it’s enjoyably rough around the edges.
The performances are all superb – particularly Jack Nicholson and Michael Keaton, who are both having a whale of a time. Only Kim Basinger seems a weak link compared to her co-stars, although I’m not sure how Sean Young would have coped in that role, before a riding accident close to filming led to her replacement by Basinger.
And while the supporting cast might not be as strong as what we’ve since seen from the Nolan films, their pedestrian performances – Pat Hingle’s impotent Commissioner Gordon, Michael Gough’s grandfatherly Albert the butler, Billy Dee William’s inconsequential Harvey Dent, Jack Palance’s non-threatening crime boss Grissom – all fit the film’s stuffy ‘40s aesthetic perfectly.
But it’s the music of the film that hasn’t aged a day. On the one hand, you have Danny Elfman’s madcap brass-heavy score, that’s spinning a dozen plates at once and managing to pull it all off without any dropping. My favourite cues are the quieter, moodier pieces like Batman and Vicki Vale’s drive towards the bat-cave (Descent Into Mystery), and a similar cue (Childhood Remembered) when Bruce Wayne finally recognises Jack Napier as the killer of his parents (a narrative shortcut I’ve never been happy with).
And then on the other hand you have the suite of pop songs by Prince. What once sounded so unnatural and futuristic now feels like a bunch of songs etched in granite they built a film around. The one musical moment I noticed on the big screen that seemed for more obvious than it does on smaller screens is the Partyman sequence where they play the song as a needle-drop, but they leave the ambient sound of the scene. It’s those shuffling sounds, and the sound of paint hitting canvas which adds to the humour of one of the film’s best moments.
Hit: Main Title
Hidden Gem: Childhood Remembered