I’ll probably get lynched for this, but I prefer Phil Collins-era Genesis to the earlier Peter Gabriel albums. I actually prefer Gabriel’s voice, it sounds other-worldly, unlike Collins’ voice which really grates with its unrelenting nasality.
But I also prefer later Genesis albums – the albums of the ‘80s, from Duke onwards – which isn’t as much an admission of a guilty pleasure, but more of a confession that I just don’t enjoy keyboard-driven prog rock. You’d think that Tony Banks’ keyboard noodlings would ramp up after the departure of guitarist Steve Hackett, but they get a bit less aggressive, probably due to Phil Collins’ pop sensibilities pushing the band into more of a commercially appealing sound.
I first heard Genesis properly on the We Can’t Dance album – which is definitely a guilty pleasure of mine. Yes, that last gasp of the band with Collins on vocals might be best described as easy-listening, but I much prefer it to this ‘70s incarnation of Genesis. This is hard-listening.
Hit: A Trick Of The Tail
Hidden Gem: Entangled